Agents search. You make the call.
Where AI pays in recruitment, and what should stay human.
Recruiters lose hours every week just finding people, while clients drown in applications. Much of the AI sold to fix it stalls. Here is where AI pays, and what should stay with people.
Fourteen hours a week, just finding people.
Recruiters say they spend 14.6 hours a week searching for candidates:1 more than a third of a 40-hour week (our arithmetic). Meanwhile LinkedIn applications rose 45% in a year, to 11,000 a minute.3 That’s the client’s problem, and it makes a short, checked list worth more: a sourced candidate is five times as likely to be hired as one who applied, 2.0% against 0.4%, at in-house teams on Gem, a vendor.4
Point AI at the right work.
Many AI projects stall, and the reasons firms give are cost, unclear value, risk and data. We read that as AI bolted onto work nobody redesigned: agents aren’t simply plug-and-play: companies urgently need to redesign how work gets done.
7 The work to hand over is search, the first sift, scheduling and notes.
of agentic AI projects will be cancelled by the end of 2027, Gartner predicts, due to escalating costs, unclear business value or inadequate risk controls.
Gartner adds: Most agentic AI projects right now are early stage experiments or proof of concepts that are mostly driven by hype and are often misapplied.
5
of companies were abandoning most of their AI initiatives, up from 17% a year before. All sectors, North America and Europe; reported March 2025.6
of staffing firms run agentic AI across their whole workflow. The barriers they name: data readiness, security, unclear plans. Nearly 2,300 surveyed; a vendor.8
None of this says people judge CVs better than software. In one study of 15 firms, managers who appeared to hire against test recommendations ended up with worse average hires, mainly shorter-staying.9 The case for people is the rest of the job.
Keep the call.
Keep the call, the relationship, persuading and closing, and accountability for who goes forward. The hardest part of today’s market is getting people to move, and that’s a human job.
of US adults oppose AI making the final hiring decision; 7% favour it. December 2022.11
permanent candidates remained reluctant to move jobs…whilst technology and AI are powerful tools, human interaction is vital to deliver the most successful recruitment outcomes for both clients and candidatesPageGroup, half-year results, August 202512
That stays yours; agents do the searching. Taste is knowing what the client never wrote down, and hearing on a call whether someone will really move.
You can bill alone. Running the business is the hard part.
At an agency, most of what you bill pays for the building. In one benchmark of UK agencies, wages took 67% of net fee income and overheads 25%, leaving 7.5% profit against the 20% it recommends.13 One accountant finds high-performing firms average a 3x return on consultant cost in fees billed.14 Alone, you keep more of it. You also take on everything else, and many new firms don’t last.
What going alone costs, before you resign
- Insurance: professional indemnity and liability.
- Tools. An agency ATS lists at $95–$215 a user a month;16 Bullhorn’s Starter at $99.17 List prices, excluding tax.
- An accountant, and your own National Insurance and pension.
- The ramp-up before your first fee lands.
- Cash flow on 30–60 day payment terms.
- Rebates when a placement leaves early.
Check your contract’s restrictive covenants. Never take your employer’s candidate or client data.
Why the usual fixes only close part of the gap.
| Option | Fits how you work | Who keeps it running | What you keep if you leave | Cost shape | Where it’s weaker |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Buy a stack of tools | You fit the tools | Each vendor | Your data, if it exports | Per seat, per month | Logins that don’t talk to each other |
| A virtual assistant or offshore sourcer | With training | You manage them | Their notes | Per hour or month | Your time managing; knowledge leaves with them |
| Build it yourself with AI coding tools | Yes, at first | You, between calls | Everything you built | Your time, then upkeep | Security and upkeep; it stops when you’re busy |
| A partner who builds and runs it (Kith) | Built around you | Kith | Your data, exported any time | A build, then monthly | You rely on a small supplier; there’s a build first |
Kith’s view, by category; no vendor is named or rated.
You run the desk. You close. Kith builds and runs the search, the first grade and the tools around you.
Do more with the team you have.
Margins are thin and permanent volumes are down. In one benchmark of UK agencies, profit ran at 7.5% of net fee income, against the 20% it recommends,13 and six in ten firms said their margins were squeezed in 2023.18 The big firms already run fewer consultants, each doing more: Hays reports group-wide consultant productivity up 5% in a year.20 In a flat market, the gain from AI is the same output with fewer hours off the phone, and better shortlists. It isn’t “more calls, more fees”.
non-billable hours a year, for ten recruiters. The 15 hours is our assumption, informed by Bullhorn’s 14.6;1 46 weeks is 52 less the 5.6-week statutory minimum leave, rounded down; our arithmetic.21
The hours come back. Decide with your team what they’re for: more searches each, better shortlists, or time on the phone.
The ATS isn’t the problem. Everything bolted round it is.
of agency recruiters rate their ATS 4 or 5 out of 5. 57% name too many tools that don’t integrate
; 67% have delayed switching software because of tech fatigue. US, 239 recruiters, a vendor survey.22
of tests found AI-written code introduced risky security flaws.25 A scan of over 5,600 public vibe-coded apps found 2,000+ vulnerabilities, 400+ exposed secrets and 175 instances of personal data.24 Both vendors.
Tools bought from partners who customise them reached deployment about twice as often as internal builds. Self-reported by 52 organisations; it doesn’t prove cause, and it’s contested.26
Vibe coding closes the fee gap, not the upkeep gap: 66% of developers say AI’s answers are almost right, but not quite
.23 That leaves AI-built apps nobody has reviewed, holding candidates’ personal data. We build with AI coding tools too, with code review and tests.
| Option | Fits how you work | Who keeps it running | What you keep if you leave | Cost shape | Where it’s weaker |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Buy another tool | You fit the tool | The vendor | Your data, if it exports | Per seat, per month | Another login that doesn’t talk to the rest |
| AI added to your current tools | Partly | The vendor | Your data, if it exports | An add-on per seat | Built for every customer, not you |
| AI-native point tools | One job, well | The vendor | Your data, if it exports | Per seat or usage | Another silo to join up |
| An offshore sourcer | With training | You manage them | Their notes | Per hour or month | Management time; turnover |
| Vibe-code it or build in-house | Yes, at first | You, or nobody | Everything you built | Your time, then upkeep | Security, upkeep, one person’s knowledge |
| A partner who builds and runs it (Kith) | Built around you | Kith | Your data, exported any time | A build, then monthly | You rely on a small supplier; there’s a build first |
Kith’s view, by category; no vendor is named or rated.
The law expects real oversight.
The law doesn’t say a person must make every hiring decision. It does say oversight has to be real: a rubber stamp isn’t oversight. UK and EU law here; US rules, such as New York City’s Local Law 144, differ and aren’t covered here.
disregard, override or reverse the output; deployers must give oversight to people with
the necessary competence, training and authority, and tell people when it’s used on them. From 2 December 2027.27
e-recruiting practices without any human intervention.28
if there is no meaningful human involvement. The UK relaxed the rule, with safeguards; decisions based on special-category data are still restricted.30
AI built around how you work, run by a partner.
People keep the calls, the relationships, and the decisions on who to contact and put forward. Here is what “AI-native” means at Kith, in things you can check:
- Software Kith builds and runs does the search and the first grade.
- A person decides who to contact and who to put forward.
- Every recommendation carries its evidence, caveats and source.
- Every decision is kept, and you can say why. Every brief is versioned.
- Your data exports any time.
Version 1, November 2026. Figures as published, quotes as written, our arithmetic marked. “Vendor”: the publisher sells to the people it surveyed. Figures we couldn’t check against the primary source or a verbatim reprint aren’t used; where a primary page was blocked, we say so. Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. Stack Overflow data under the Open Database License. Pew Research Center bears no responsibility for the analyses or interpretations of the data presented here.
- Bullhorn, GRID 2025 Industry Trends Report, 2025. 1,500+ recruitment professionals worldwide. Vendor. bullhorn.com
- LinkedIn, Future of Recruiting 2025. Survey September 2024; 1,271 recruiting leaders, mostly in-house, 23 countries. Vendor. business.linkedin.com
- Semafor, reporting LinkedIn figures from the New York Times, 24 June 2025. semafor.com
- Gem, 2025 Recruiting Benchmarks, 16 January 2025. In-house teams on Gem, 2021–2024. Vendor. gem.com
- Gartner, press release, 25 June 2025, as reprinted verbatim by HPCwire. A prediction. hpcwire.com
- S&P Global Market Intelligence, via CIO Dive, 14 March 2025. 1,000+ respondents, North America and Europe. ciodive.com
- BCG, press release, 30 September 2025. 1,250 executives. Vendor. bcg.com
- Bullhorn, GRID 2026, press release, 25 February 2026. Nearly 2,300 respondents, November–December 2025. Vendor. bullhorn.com
- Hoffman, Kahn & Li, “Discretion in Hiring”, Quarterly Journal of Economics 133(2), 2018. 15 firms, low-skill service jobs; worse means mainly shorter tenure. doi:10.1093/qje/qjx042
- Jamie Kohn (Gartner), HR Dive, 20 January 2026. Gartner Q3 2025 survey of 2,901 candidates. hrdive.com
- Pew Research Center, “AI in Hiring and Evaluating Workers: What Americans Think”, 20 April 2023. 11,004 US adults, 12–18 December 2022. pewresearch.org
- PageGroup, Half Year Results, 12 August 2025. investors.michaelpage.com
- Recruitment Accountants with APSCo, benchmark for H1 2026, 3 September 2026. The firm’s own clients; sample not published; the 20% is its own model. uk.apsco.org
- Recruitment Accountants, Q1 2025 benchmark. A rule of thumb. recruitmentaccountants.com
- Office for National Statistics, ad hoc AH1574, 10 October 2024. Our arithmetic. ons.gov.uk
- Recruit CRM, pricing, Pro to Enterprise, checked 8 November 2026. recruitcrm.io
- Bullhorn, pricing, Starter, checked 8 November 2026. bullhorn.com
- REC, Industry Status Report 2022/23. Survey September–October 2023, 274 members. rec.uk.com
- REC, press release, 8 December 2025. Estimates modelled by Cebr from 186 recruiters. rec.uk.com
- Hays, FY25 investor deck. Productivity is group-wide. haysplc.com
- GOV.UK, Holiday entitlement. gov.uk
- Top Echelon, 1 August 2025. 239 agency recruiters, US. Vendor. topechelon.com
- Stack Overflow, 2025 Developer Survey, AI section. Base 31,476. survey.stackoverflow.co
- Escape.tech, 29 October 2025. A passive scan; the authors call it a lower bound. Vendor. escape.tech
- Veracode, 2025 GenAI Code Security Report, October 2025. 100+ models; Java, JavaScript, Python and C#. Vendor. veracode.com
- MIT NANDA, The GenAI Divide: State of AI in Business 2025, July 2025. 52 organisations; hybrid builds not measured. mirror at mlq.ai
- EU AI Act, Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 as amended by 2026/1744: Annex III 4(a), Articles 6(3), 14(4)(d), 26(2), 26(11). eur-lex.europa.eu
- GDPR, Article 22 and Recital 71. gdpr-info.eu
- Court of Justice of the EU, C-634/21 (SCHUFA), 7 December 2023. eur-lex.europa.eu
- Data (Use and Access) Act 2025, section 80; in force 5 February 2026. legislation.gov.uk